The decision to file or not to file for
Bankruptcy as well the timing of any Bankruptcy filing involves many complex legal issues. We are not
permitted to provide legal advice and recommend that you consult with
an experienced bankruptcy attorney who will be able to advise you.
If you decide to act as your own attorney you should do the necessary legal research to evaluate the specific issues presented by your individual
situation and should be aware that the Bankruptcy Court will hold you to
the same standards applied to licensed attorneys.
The purpose of this section is to give you an overview of the Bankruptcy
process and it does not constitute legal advice.
Should I file for bankruptcy?
Whether
to file for bankruptcy is a very personal decision. Some people do not have any
assets over and above what the law allows them to keep, even if they do not pay
their creditors. If this is true of you, then you don't need a bankruptcy in
order to protect your assets.
Some
people find it helpful to file a bankruptcy case anyway, because their
financial situation is causing them emotional distress or depression, or
because they are looking forward to a bright future and would like to free
themselves of debt now and have their income and assets to themselves in the
future. Also, some people may find that a bankruptcy is worth filing, even if
they do lose some of their assets.
Considering Bankruptcy Checklist
If
several of the following apply in your situation, you might consider
bankruptcy:
- Your wages have been garnished or
your bank account has been attached
- Most of your debts are unsecured
debts like credit card bills, hospital or doctor's bills, etc.
- Your total debt, not including
your a car or house loan, is more than you could pay, even over five or
more years
- Collection agencies are calling
you at home and/or at work
- Your payments are more than 30
days behind on more than one bill
- There are lawsuits pending
against you
- You have high medical bills not
covered by insurance
- You owe income taxes that you are
unable to currently pay
- You have few assets
- You have little or no savings
- You have had property repossessed
(such as a vehicle)
People
who have had their wages garnished can especially benefit from a bankruptcy
because the bankruptcy will stop the garnishment and may even help you get some
of the garnished money back.
General Concepts
1. What are the main purposes of bankruptcy?
Bankruptcy laws serve two main
purposes. First, bankruptcy law gives creditors some payment on their debts if
a debtor (the one who owes the debt) can afford to pay them. Second, bankruptcy
law gives debtors a fresh start, by canceling many of their debts, through an
order of the court called a discharge.
2. What are the different kinds of bankruptcy?
There are four types of bankruptcy
available to individuals:
- Chapter
7 (a liquidation-style case for individuals or businesses),
- Chapter
13 (a payment plan or rehabilitation-style case for individuals with a
regular source of income),
- Chapter
12 (a payment plan or rehabilitation-style case for family farmers and
fishermen), and
- Chapter
11 (a more complex rehabilitation-style case used primarily by business
debtors, but sometimes by individuals with substantial debts and asset).
The two most important types of
cases for consumers are chapter 7 and chapter 13. Both provide for some
possible payments to creditors, a discharge for debtors and supervision by a
trustee. Chapter 7 involves surrendering some of your property (at least in
theory) in return for a discharge of many of your debts. The trustee sells any non-exempt property
and pays your creditors. In chapter 13, you keep your property but must commit
to a three- to five-year repayment plan. You then obtain a discharge of most of
the debts not paid in the plan.
In both types of bankruptcy, most
creditors must stop efforts to collect debts after your case is filed. This
protection is called the "automatic stay." In a chapter 7, this relief is often
temporary.
3. What is the difference between chapter 7 and
chapter 13?
Chapter 7: A Brief Overview
Chapter 7 is designed as a
liquidation or sell-out type of bankruptcy. Under this model, debtors give up
certain property that they own at the time they file the bankruptcy case, which
is sold by a trustee. The trustee uses the proceeds of the sale to pay
creditors. This is the way many cases proceed. In other cases, probably most
cases, the debtor does not have any assets over and above what the law allows
the debtor to keep. Thus, in most chapter 7 cases, the debtor does not give up
any property. Still, we call chapter 7 cases liquidation cases.
About 90 days after a chapter 7
case is filed, most debtors get most of their debts discharged. This means the
debts have gone away. Some debts do not go away,
and must be paid after the case. Examples include past-due child support
payments, some taxes and student loans. Debts for which the debtor has pledged
collateral for the loan (such as cars, homes and household goods) also do not
go away in a bankruptcy.
The bankruptcy case addresses only
the debts the debtor has at the time of the bankruptcy case. Future debts must
always be paid as usual. Debtors are allowed to keep the money that they earn
after filing the bankruptcy case, as well as most other property that they
obtain after the filing.
Chapter 13: A Brief Overview
Chapter 13 is very different. The
model is one of pay out rather than sell out. Debtors pay some of their debts
over time.
Debtors in chapter 13 usually keep
all of their property, whether or not it is exempt, but they make regular
payments on their debts out of the money that they earn after filing the
bankruptcy case. The plan payments must total at least as much as creditors
would have received if the debtor had just liquidated under chapter 7. The
payments are made to a trustee, who distributes the payments to the creditors.
The payments are made in regular
installments, according to a payment plan (called a chapter 13 plan) that the
debtor proposes, usually with the help of an attorney. The plan lasts either
until the debts are paid in full or until the end of a three- to five-year
period. The debtor receives a discharge at the completion of the plan.
This was just an overview. More detail
is provided throughout this FAQ.
4. Does a debtor have to "qualify" for
bankruptcy? How will I know if I am eligible?
Chapter 7 Eligibility
Today's law allows debtors, for the
most part, to choose the type of bankruptcy they want to file, though there are
reasons a debtor might choose one chapter over another.
For example, a chapter 13 case
allows a debtor to catch up on missed payments owed to creditors holding a
security interest in collateral, such as a mortgage or auto lender, and
therefore might be a better choice for some
debtors. As long as the debtor's plan has been approved by
the court and the debtor is maintaining payments to the trustee, the collateral
will be protected from repossession.
For cases filed on or after October 17, 2005, access to chapter 7 will be more limited. Individual debtors with
primarily consumer debts who want to file a case under chapter 7 will have
their finances examined to determine if they can afford to pay creditors. If
they can, based on a set formula know as the "means test," they will not be
eligible to file a chapter 7.
If they want to file a bankruptcy,
they will need to file a chapter 13. The "means test" is designed to force
people who can afford to pay some of their creditors to do so rather than
discharging all their debts in a chapter 7.
The means test compares the
debtor's excess monthly income to the amount of unsecured debt to determine how
much a debtor could repay to creditors if he were in a chapter 13. Because this
calculation is hypothetical and does not necessarily reflect the debtor's true
financial condition, a debtor who appears to be able to repay the minimum
portion of his debts but who, in reality, cannot, may be permitted to stay in a
chapter 7 case. Unfortunately, the means test is more complicated than we can
explain well here.
Chapter 13 Eligibility
There are two principal
requirements for eligibility in a chapter 13 cases. First, the debtor must have
regular income, although this need not be from a job-regular benefit payments
or rental income would qualify. Second, the debtor must not have debts over a
certain amount. The debt limits are $922,975 in secured debt (like home
mortgages and auto loans), and $307,675 in unsecured debt (like most credit
card debt). These numbers are good through April 1, 2006, and go up every year.
5. How does bankruptcy help me in the short run?
By imposing an injunction against
all collection efforts by creditors, which means creditors must stop calling,
sending letters or suing you over your debts. This is called the automatic stay
and is discussed in more detail below.
6. What is a discharge?
If a debt is discharged, the debtor
no longer has an obligation to pay the debt and the creditor may not make any
effort to compel the debtor to repay. However, if some other person (such as a
relative or friend) also has an obligation to pay, their obligation is not
discharged. In addition, if the debtor has property that is collateral for a
loan, the creditor may still be able to repossess that collateral.
7. Do all debts get discharged?
No, not all debts will be discharged
through the bankruptcy, even if a debtor has satisfactorily performed all of
his duties in a case. First, a bankruptcy case only discharges debts that the
debtor owed at the time the case was filed, not those incurred after the case
was filed.
Debts that are not discharged
include debts for certain taxes, certain unscheduled debts (creditors with
debts not listed in your paperwork), alimony, maintenance or support debts,
pre-petition fines or restitution, debts for injury or death caused by a debtor's
use of drugs or alcohol, some government backed student loans and certain condo
or co-op fees.
Other debts that may not be
discharged include debts incurred through fraud or by willful or malicious
actions of the debtor. If the creditor does not ask the court to rule on these
debts, they will be discharged.
Bankruptcy Procedures
1. If I decide to file for bankruptcy, what do I
have to do before I file?
Today, a debtor simply needs to
carefully consider whether bankruptcy is the right choice for them, and then
gather the paperwork we talk about later in this FAQ.
As of October 17, 2005, in order to be eligible to file bankruptcy, debtors will be required to receive credit
counseling within the 180 days prior to filing. Specifically, the law requires
debtors to receive, from an approved agency, a briefing outlining the
opportunities for credit counseling and help with a budget analysis. This may
be done alone or in a group, either in person, on the phone, or even on the
Internet. If, due to an emergency, a debtor is unable to obtain credit
counseling services from an approved agency during the 5-day period prior to
filing, the requirement will be excused, but must be fulfilled within 30 days
after filing.
Once it is available, a list of
approved non-profit budget and credit counseling agencies can be found at the
office of the United States Trustee
or at the bankruptcy court Clerk's office.
2. What documents do I need to file in a chapter
7 case?
Today a debtor needs to file these
forms, all of which are best prepared by an attorney, but are also available in
any bankruptcy court:
- the
bankruptcy petition;
- a list
of creditors;
- a
schedule of assets and liabilities;
- a
schedule of current income and current expenditures; and
- a
statement of the debtor's financial affairs.
As of October 17, 2005, debtors will be required to file more paperwork. Failure to file these documents, or to be
excused by the court from filing them, will result in an automatic dismissal of
your case. As a result, it is more necessary than before to use an attorney to
file your case. In cases filed on or after October 17, 2005, debtors must file:
- the
bankruptcy petition;
- a list
of creditors;
- a
schedule of assets and liabilities;
- a
schedule of current income and current expenditures;
- a
statement of the debtor's financial affairs;
- a
certificate from the attorney or bankruptcy petition preparer (if there is
one) indicating that the debtor received a notice describing the different
bankruptcy chapters and the services available from the credit counseling
agencies as well as a statement specifying that anyone who knowingly or
fraudulently conceals assets or makes a false statement under oath is
subject to fine, imprisonment or both; (if no one assisted the debtor,
then the debtor must file a certificate that such notice was received from
the court and read by the debtor);
- copies
of all pay stubs received by the debtor within 60 days before filing;
- a
statement of the debtor's monthly net income itemized to show how it is
calculated;
- a
statement disclosing a reasonably anticipated increase in income or
expenditures over the following 12 months;
- if the
debtor has property that secures a debt, such as a car or home, a
statement of intention with respect to treatment of the property in
bankruptcy;
- a
certificate from the approved non-profit budget and credit counseling
agency that describes the services provided to the debtor and a copy of
the debt repayment plan, if any, developed by that agency;
- a
record of any interest that the debtor has in an individual retirement
account; and,
- an
analysis of the means test.
If the debtor fails to file all of
information noted above, with the exception of the last 4, within 45 days of
filing the petition, the case will be automatically dismissed.
Your attorney will need certain
documents from you to file these documents with the court, which are listed
below.
Information to Take With You When Consulting a Bankruptcy
Attorney
- A copy
of every bill or letter you have received from a collection agency,
- A copy
of any lawsuit or pleading you have received in a case in which you are
involved,
- Two pay
stubs representing an average pay period. Include pay stubs for your
spouse, even if they are not filing bankruptcy with you,
- Deeds
to real estate in which you have any (even a partial) interest. This
includes real estate you are purchasing or that you already own,
- The
original or memorandum title for any cars, trucks, trailers, boats,
motorcycles, mobile or motor homes you own or are purchasing, or other
documents showing the value of your assets,
- Appraisals
of your home, jewelry, etc., if you have them,
- Any
policies of life insurance you have on your life, and/or the life of your
spouse or children. Where possible, you should contact the agent who sold
you the policy and find out if the policy has any "cash surrender value."
If your policy has "cash surrender value," please provide your attorney
with that value, and
- Income
Tax Returns filed in the previous two (2) years.
3. What will happen in my chapter 7 case after I
file all these documents?
Chapter 7 cases are pretty simple
for the most part. In most cases, you will attend one creditors' meeting and
just wait for your discharge notice to come in the mail.
The creditors' meeting, which is
also called a 341 meeting (named after the section of the bankruptcy law that
requires the meeting), is run by your bankruptcy trustee, who will question you
about all of the information contained in your bankruptcy documents.
In a simple case, the meeting will
usually last just 5 minutes or so. While all creditors are invited to attend,
very few actually do. Be sure to bring a form of identification to the meeting,
as well as proof of your Social Security number (usually your Social Security
card). The trustee may ask you to provide additional documentation during the
meeting, and give you a few days to produce it.
The discharge notice will arrive in
the mail about 60 days after you attend the creditors' meeting. This piece of
paper is proof that most of your debts have been discharged. You should keep it
in a safe place.
4. Are there additional documents and other
requirements in a chapter 13 case? What is required in the chapter 13 plan?
If you are filing a chapter 13
case, rather than a chapter 7, in addition to the documents mentioned above,
you must file a plan that describes how much you will pay your creditors and
over what time period. Your plan must provide that you pay creditors at least
what they could have received in chapter 7 liquidation case, which basically
means creditors must receive payments equal to the value of your non-exempt
assets.
In addition, the plan must provide
that you contribute all of your "disposable income" to the plan. Disposable
income is the income above what is necessary for the support of the debtor and
family. However, in many cases that amount is determined by the means test
formula.
The means test is a very
complicated test, but essentially requires that you average your income over
the past six months (from any source including regular gifts from family
members), then deduct a series of allowed expenses, and see what is left to pay
creditors. You will most likely need an attorney to complete this analysis.
The chapter 13 plan lasts either
until the debts are paid in full or until the end of a three- to five-year
period. (For certain low income debtors the maximum plan period without court
approval is three years. For other debtors, creditors may be able to insist
that the debtor pay a five-year plan).
Within 30 days of filing your
petition, you must begin making payments under your plan. The payments are made
to a trustee, who distributes the payments to the creditors.
Like in a chapter 7 case, after
filing the bankruptcy petition, you will be required to attend a creditors'
meeting (also known as a 341 meeting, named after the section of the bankruptcy
law that requires the meeting). The meeting will be run by the chapter 13
trustee, who will question you about the paperwork you filed in your case. This
creditors' meeting will last longer than a meeting in a chapter 7 case. The
trustee will likely question you about your income and your expenses, and may
also require additional documentation at the meeting.
Before the court will approve your
plan, you must file all required tax returns due within the last four years.
Prior to October 17, 2005, you can normally just give your prior tax returns to
your chapter 13 trustee.
After completing payments under the
plan and completing any financial counseling required, the debtor will receive
a discharge of any debts not paid under the plan.
5. Must I produce tax returns before and after my
bankruptcy?
Today, many trustees require tax
returns for chapter 13 cases, and some also require them for chapter 7 cases.
In most jurisdictions, it is enough to produce the past two tax returns, but
this varies throughout the country.
For cases filed on or after October 17, 2005, you may be required to provide the trustee and/or any creditor with
copies of any federal tax return that was filed for the year prior to filing.
If you do not comply with this request, your bankruptcy case may be dismissed.
You will also be required to file
with the bankruptcy court copies of any federal tax returns filed during the
case.
Any taxing authority may request
dismissal of a bankruptcy case if you fail to file all required tax returns.
6. Do all creditors have to be listed on
bankruptcy schedules?
All of your debts have to be listed,
with the name and address of the creditors. This is so creditors receive notice
of the bankruptcy and get their fair share of any money that is paid to
creditors. Sometimes debtors think that they should omit a creditor because
they want to continue to pay the debt. This would violate the law, and it is
unnecessary, because you can always choose to pay a debt voluntarily, even
though the debt has been discharged and there is no legal obligation to make
payment. However, creditors are prohibited from taking any action to collect
discharged debts.
7. What should I do if I discover that I forgot
to list a creditor in their bankruptcy schedules?
As soon as you realize that a
creditor has been omitted, you should notify your attorney and provide him or
her with all of the information necessary to complete the schedule (the amount
of the debt, the type and value of any collateral, and the name and address of
the creditor).
In some cases, failure to list a
creditor will result in harm to the creditor, such as if the creditor missed an
opportunity to participate in the bankruptcy and/or receive payments. If this
happens, your attorney can advise you about what additional action, if any, is
necessary.
If an omitted creditor demands
payment of the debt, you should inform the creditor of the bankruptcy, as
discussed below.
8. What should I do if a creditor demands payment
of a debt after my case is filed?
Most efforts by a creditor to
collect a pre-petition debt (one that is owed by you as of the filing for your
case) or to obtain your property without the permission of the bankruptcy court
are violations of the automatic stay.
A creditor who knowingly violates
the automatic stay may be punished by the court and is liable to the debtor for
harm caused. If a debt has not been listed on the schedules filed with the
court, the creditor may not be on notice of the bankruptcy. Therefore, you
should inform the creditor of your bankruptcy and request that the creditor
stop the collection efforts.
If you are represented by an
attorney, you should give the creditor your attorney's name and telephone
number. If you are not represented by an attorney, you should give the creditor
additional information about the case-the date of filing, the court in which
the case was filed and the case number. If improper collection action
continues, you should consult with an attorney, notify the trustee or seek
protection from the court.
9. Is there anything I should know about the
timing of my case?
Probably the most important thing
you need to know is that once you have decided to file for bankruptcy, you need
to stop using your credit cards. Anything that you charge knowing you will not
pay the money back is fraud under the bankruptcy law and the debt will not be
discharged. Also, if you charge luxury goods within two or three months of the
filing, or take out cash advances right before your case, the debt is presumed
to be non-dischargeable even if you did not know you were filing for bankruptcy
when you charged the items or took out the cash advances. In many cases, it is
better to wait a while after these transactions before filing for bankruptcy.
More Details on the Bankruptcy Process
1. How much property can I keep after filing?
Chapter 7
Every state has "exemption" laws
that allows people to keep some assets, free from creditors' claims, even if
they do not pay their creditors. The idea is that it would do little good to
take all of a person's assets because he or she would not have a place to live,
clothes to wear or a way to get to work. Most exemptions allow a person to keep
clothes, household goods, a car of some limited value, tools of trade, as well
as other property. Some exemptions allow the debtor to keep some equity in a
house.
In addition, bankruptcy law
contains federal exemptions, which can be used when a person is in bankruptcy,
at least in some states. Those laws list the type and amount of property you
can keep. These federal exemptions are available to debtors who live in Arkansas, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Texas, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin. People who live in these states can essentially choose the state
or the federal scheme, based upon the assets the person has. One scheme may be
great for one person, but horrible for another.
As we described above, the debtor
must give all non-exempt assets (the ones that do not fit within the
exemptions) to the bankruptcy trustee. However, for many people the amount of
the exemptions exceeds the value of the property they own, and thus they do not
need to surrender any property. Despite the exemptions, you always need to take
care of secured creditors. Their claims are not affected by your exemptions.
Chapter 13
Under chapter 13, you will not have
to surrender any property. Remember that you can instead essentially buy back
the non-exempt assets by paying at least this value to your unsecured creditors
under your chapter 13 plan. You may, however, have to give up property that is
collateral for a debt.
2. What is the difference between secured
creditors and unsecured creditors?
A "secured creditor" is a creditor
that has a lien on property. A lien is an interest in property that a creditor
can use to satisfy a debt. Some liens are voluntary, for example a mortgage or
a security interest in a car. Other liens are involuntary, for example a lien
on property resulting from unpaid taxes or a judgment.
An "unsecured creditor" is a
creditor who has no interest in any particular property of the debtor. Outside
of bankruptcy, there are only two ways an unsecured creditor can get paid.
First, the debtor can pay voluntarily. This is the way most debts are paid. The
other way unsecured creditors get paid is much harder. They must sue the debtor,
get a judgment against the debtor, and ask the sheriff to seize some property
of the debtor and sell it to satisfy the creditor's claim.
Even in bankruptcy, the secured
creditor has greater protection because its lien on the debtor's property is usually
honored. The bankruptcy does not remove it.
3. Does a bankruptcy case automatically remove
liens-such as mortgages-against a debtor's property?
No, not at all. Secured creditors
get extraordinary rights in a bankruptcy case. Bankruptcy may temporarily delay
secured creditors, but most voluntary liens (those granted by agreement on
houses, cars and household goods) have to be satisfied one way or another.
However, the debtor has some
opportunities to remove or avoid involuntary liens and a small category of
voluntary liens. "Avoid" is the term used in the Bankruptcy Code for removing
liens.
Chapter 7
Debtors can avoid some involuntary
liens (except for liens securing alimony or support obligations) that are on
property that the debtor could exempt. Debtors can also avoid some voluntary
liens on property that the debtor could exempt. For these voluntary liens,
debtors can only remove liens on certain household goods, "tools of the trade"
and professionally prescribed health aids. Moreover, the term "household goods"
includes only certain types of items (for example, clothing, 1 radio, 1
television, 1 VCR).
Chapter 13
The chapter 13 debtor has the
additional ability to remove liens by completing payments under the plan. In
some cases, the plan will reduce the amount that the debtor must pay or change
the time period over which the debt must be paid. In the case of homes and cars
(at least as of October 17, 2005), the ability to change the payment terms is
very limited.
4. How does the automatic stay work, to stop
foreclosures, repossessions or other collection efforts from taking place?
Just by filing a bankruptcy
petition, an "automatic stay" against all collection efforts is put in place.
This is a powerful tool of bankruptcy, and one of the law's primary protections
for debtors. Most creditors have to stop all efforts to collect from a
bankruptcy debtor. Creditors must stop making calls to the debtor, stop sending
letters, stop all lawsuits to collect, etc.
The automatic stay also stops
foreclosures, repossessions or sales of property from going forward. If you
don't pay your house payments, however, the creditor will have the right to
continue the foreclosure once the dust settles. Thus, the benefits of the
automatic stay are often temporary when the creditor is a secured creditor.
There are a number of exceptions to
the automatic stay. For example, attempts to establish or collect alimony or
support obligations are not stayed, nor are criminal suits or suits by
governmental agencies to protect the public.
Moreover, the automatic stay does
not arise if you are filing a case within a year of filing two other bankruptcy
cases that were dismissed because you did not file all the paperwork or
otherwise follow through in your cases. If this happens, the stay is not
automatic, but you can still request the protection of a stay.
Just remember that as to secured
creditors, the automatic stay is temporary. It means only that creditors must
ask the court before taking action. No bankruptcy filing allows a debtor to keep
property that is security for a loan without making payments on the loan. If
the debtor is behind on the payments and the property is of insufficient value
to satisfy the debt, or there is risk of loss of the property, a secured
creditor may obtain court permission to seize and sell the property.
In addition, in a chapter 7 case,
as soon as the bankruptcy case is closed, the automatic stay terminates, and
the creditor can proceed with foreclosure or repossession if the debtor is
behind on the payments.
People with problems with secured
debt are frequently better off filing a chapter 13 case than a chapter 7 case
because the chapter 13 will allow the debtor to pay off the past-due secured
debt over time.
In chapter 13, the automatic stay
also protects people other than the debtor who are "co-debtors." Co-debtors are
people who also have an obligation to pay the same debt as the debtor. That
includes people who have guaranteed the debt for the debtor.
5. What must I do to prevent foreclosures and
repossessions?
Chapter 7
Soon after filing the petition, the
debtor must declare whether he will return the property, purchase the property
or enter into a reaffirmation agreement with the creditor. However, if the
debtor does not do one of these things, the stay will terminate and the
creditor may take the property.
Chapter 13
Depending upon the plan, you may be
able to keep property despite secured claims. You can modify some obligations,
for example by stretching out payments and reducing interest rates (where interest
rates have fallen since you created the obligation).
6. How does a chapter 13 case help me with my
secured debts?
Generally, all loans secured by the
debtor's residence must be paid in full in a chapter 13. The good thing is that
the case gives the debtor time to pay this off in the plan, unlike a chapter 7.
Overdue payments must be repaid over the course of the plan, along with the
regular monthly payments. Practically speaking, this means that a chapter 13
debtor who was behind on the mortgage payment will be making a larger mortgage
payment to make up for the past due debt.
Today, other collateral securing
loans are treated differently. For cases filed before October 17, 2005, a debtor must only pay for the "value" of the collateral, rather than the amount of
the loan, through the plan. For example, if the debtor's car is worth $5,000
but the loan on the car is $6,000, the debtor's plan must pay the car lender
$5,000. The remaining $1,000 (the difference between the value of the car and
the loan amount) will receive the same treatment and payments as any other
unsecured debt. This analysis also applies to other debts incurred to purchase
personal property and secured by the property.
For cases filed on or after October 17, 2005, the treatment of collateral other than home mortgages will change
significantly. Cars purchased for the personal use of the debtor within 910
days (approximately 2½ years) prior to the filing of the bankruptcy are
required to be paid in full through the bankruptcy. Any other secured property
of value that was purchased in the year before filing must also be paid in
full. However, the debtor still may be able to reduce the interest rate on
secured debts.
7. What can be done if a debtor falls behind in
payments after filing a chapter 13 case?
Debtors who have unexpected
financial problems in a chapter 13 case should immediately consult with their
attorneys. It is often possible to deal with changed circumstances by amending
the chapter 13 plan. Also, it is sometimes possible to add to the plan debts
that were incurred after the chapter 13 case is filed, so that they will be
discharged with other debts at the completion of the plan.
8. What is a reaffirmation agreement and how does
it work?
A reaffirmation agreement is
essentially an agreement providing that the debtor will pay a creditor's debt
even though the debt would otherwise be discharged in bankruptcy. In theory,
the debt can be renegotiated but most reaffirmation agreements simply require
the debtor to pay the debt as originally agreed.
While unsecured debts can be
reaffirmed, this is usually not a good idea. Thus, most reaffirmation
agreements deal with secured debts and are entered into to keep the creditor
from repossessing or foreclosing on the property. A valid reaffirmation
agreement puts the debtor under a legal obligation to repay the otherwise
dischargeable debt. If the debtor defaults on the payments required under the
reaffirmation agreement, the creditor can repossess or foreclose on property
and seek a personal judgment against the debtor.
In order for a reaffirmation to be
valid, the parties must sign the agreement and file it with the court before
the debtor receives a discharge. In addition, either the debtor's attorney or
the court must determine that the agreement does not impose an "undue hardship"
on the debtor's family. There are other requirements as well.
A reaffirmation agreement is
voluntary. Neither the debtor nor the creditor must agree to it. In addition,
the debtor usually has some time to rescind the agreement.
If the parties do not comply with
any of the requirements for a reaffirmation, the agreement may not be binding.
In that event, the debtor would have no personal obligation to make payments
under the agreement.
As a rule, debtors should think
very carefully about whether to reaffirm debt as this limits the debtor's
bankruptcy discharge.
9. Can a debtor make payments on a discharged
debt without a reaffirmation agreement?
Yes. The debtor can make a
voluntary payment of the debt. This often happens, for example, with debts to
family members or friends. However, the key to this kind of payment is that it
must be entirely voluntary; the debtor has no legal obligation to pay a
discharged debt, and the creditors can take no action to pressure or persuade
the debtor into making the payments.
10. Can I obtain bankruptcy protection again if
have filed a bankruptcy in the past and am now falling behind in payments
again?
You may not be able file a
bankruptcy petition if a prior case was dismissed because of your failure to
abide by a court order. In addition, you cannot file again if, within the last
six months, you requested dismissal of the prior case after a creditor sought
relief from the automatic stay. The new law also imposes the following rules on
debtors who have filed prior bankruptcy cases, effective October 17, 2005.
Chapter 7
A debtor can file another chapter 7
case, but there might not be a right to discharge. If the prior bankruptcy was
in chapter 7, the debtor filed the case less than eight years ago (six years up
to October 17, 2005) and obtained a discharge, he cannot obtain a discharge in
a case filed today.
Finally, having filed a recent
previous bankruptcy may affect the automatic stay. This is true in some
situations where the prior case had been dismissed or a creditor had obtained
relief from the automatic stay.
Chapter 13
A debtor can file another chapter
13 case, but there might not be a right to discharge. On or after October 17, 2005, if the prior bankruptcy was in chapter 7, the debtor filed less than
four years ago and obtained a discharge, he cannot obtain a discharge in a case
filed today. If the prior bankruptcy was in chapter 13, the debtor filed the
petition less than two years ago, and obtained a discharge, he cannot obtain a
discharge in a chapter 13 filed today.
Finally, having filed a recent
previous bankruptcy may affect the automatic stay. This is true in some
situations where the prior case had been dismissed or a creditor had obtained
relief from the automatic stay.
The End of Your Bankruptcy Case
1. Once a chapter 7 or chapter 13 case is
completed, are there other requirements before a debtor receives a discharge?
After October 17, 2005, all debtors (with limited exceptions) must complete an instructional course in personal
financial management from an approved agency prior to receiving a discharge.
In a chapter 13 case, a debtor who
owes a domestic support obligation must also certify to the court that all
amounts due have been paid.
2. How do I know when my bankruptcy case is
completed, and I am no longer in bankruptcy?
At the conclusion of an
individual's bankruptcy case, the court enters an order closing the case, and a
copy of this order is sent to the debtor. Unless the trustee has assets to
distribute to creditors, case closing takes place fairly quickly in chapter 7
cases. In chapter 13, the case will not be closed until after the debtor
finishes making payments under the plan. The case will also be closed if the
court dismisses the case.
Bankruptcy and Your Future Relationship with
Credit
1. How does bankruptcy affect my credit rating?
Issuers of credit (like banks and
credit card companies) are free to consider the fact of a bankruptcy filing in
deciding whether to extend credit. Credit reports may list bankruptcy filings
for up to 10 years. Some issuers of credit may decide to extend credit
regardless of a bankruptcy. Others may be willing to extend credit only after a
number of years have passed, or until the bankruptcy filing is no longer on the
credit report. After bankruptcy, it may be difficult to rent an apartment.
Lately, some creditors have been
offering credit to bankruptcy debtors more freely than other people in
financial difficulty because the debtor cannot file another bankruptcy for many
years to come. In that sense, the debtor is a good credit risk. For the most
part though, for obvious reasons, it is best for bankruptcy debtors to avoid
credit as much as possible after bankruptcy.
2. What can debtors do to reestablish their
credit after filing bankruptcy?
In some jurisdictions there may be
debtor education programs offered in connection with chapter 13 cases that can
help debtors reestablish credit. Where such programs are not available, debtors
may be able to obtain a "secured" credit card, which requires that the debtor
deposit funds with the credit card issuer. This provides the opportunity to
show responsible use of credit, which is a major factor in any lender's credit
decisions. Other major factors are length of employment and length of residency.
3. How can debtors obtain a copy of their credit
reports and correct any errors?
All persons are entitled to one free creditor report per year,
from each of the three approved credit agencies. Additionally, whenever a
debtor's application for credit is denied, the credit issuer is required to
give any debtor who requests one a copy of any credit report that was used in
making the decision.
If there are errors in a report, such
as an incorrect Social Security number or a debt that is not owed, the debtor
should make a request for correction in writing to the bureau, enclosing copies
of any documents that would establish the correct facts.